Liverpool legend Graeme Souness has voiced concerns about Bruno Fernandes, describing the Manchester United midfielder as a “liability” and urging manager Ruben Amorim to assess his long-term role at the club.
At 30, Fernandes remains one of United’s most consistent performers since Sir Alex Ferguson’s departure, standing out in an era marred by instability.
Since joining from Sporting Lisbon in 2020, the Portuguese playmaker has delivered 85 goals and 76 assists, contributing to FA Cup and Carabao Cup triumphs. In 2023, he replaced Harry Maguire as captain and became one of the club’s highest earners, second only to Casemiro.
However, Fernandes’ on-field behavior has drawn criticism. His reactions during games—such as complaining to teammates or gesturing in frustration—have been labeled as poor leadership traits.
In his Mail Online column, Souness echoed these sentiments, highlighting how Fernandes’ negative demeanor could harm young talents like Kobbie Mainoo, Amad Diallo, and Alejandro Garnacho. Following Fernandes’ dismissal in United’s 2-0 defeat to Wolves, Souness questioned whether Amorim should continue relying on him.
“Fernandes is easily their most talented player with the ball,” Souness remarked. “He can deliver incredible passes, but his overall game has glaring flaws.
His behavior—throwing his arms in frustration, shrugging at teammates—is not what you expect from a captain. What example does this set for young players trying to develop at the club?”
While acknowledging Fernandes’ creative brilliance, Souness criticized his lack of mental toughness and discipline, especially in high-pressure moments.
He referenced Fernandes’ performance during United’s 7-0 humiliation at Liverpool last year, saying, “When the team was three goals down, he gave up—pointing fingers, sulking. That’s not what leaders do. Mental toughness and discipline are what define great players, and Fernandes falls short.”
Souness also reflected on his own experience as Liverpool captain, sharing how strong dressing rooms handle such behavior. “In successful teams, this negativity would have been dealt with immediately. Senior players would make sure there was no room for such antics,” he wrote.
Manchester United’s recent form has compounded their struggles. Amorim has already overseen five defeats since replacing interim boss Ruud van Nistelrooy, with the club sitting in 14th place after a Boxing Day loss to Wolves.
Unitedly now face Newcastle on Monday night in a crucial clash at Old Trafford, where Fernandes and his teammates will be desperate to turn their fortunes around.
With the team languishing in the league table and Fernandes under fire for his leadership style, the question remains: does he have a future at Manchester United under Ruben Amorim?