Jamie Carragher did not hold back as he criticized Liverpool’s goalkeeper, Caoimhin Kelleher, following a dramatic 3-3 draw with Newcastle United.
The Premier League leaders had fought back from two deficits, with Curtis Jones and a brace from Mohamed Salah countering goals from Alexander Isak and Anthony Gordon. However, a late mix-up cost Liverpool a crucial win.
Newcastle’s Fabian Schar capitalized on Kelleher’s hesitation to latch onto an outswinging free-kick, converting from an improbable angle.
The decision by Kelleher to pull out of a seemingly easy catch left Carragher baffled during The Overlap’s watchalong. “If you can catch it, you catch it! What was he doing? I can’t believe he’s not just caught the ball,” Carragher exclaimed.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f6eae/f6eae828a057afc2067ebe41d7ef3a4f25f74e98" alt="Jamie Carragher Explodes Over Liverpool Keeper’s Blunder in Newcastle Thriller 130 Caoimhin Kelleher"
Kelleher Under Scrutiny
While Kelleher has impressed in Alisson’s absence, his late mistake cast doubt over his consistency in high-pressure situations. Ian Wright added to the critique, stating, “The goalkeeper has had a mare. He probably thought it was going out.”
With rumors linking Kelleher to a move to Chelsea, this high-profile error might influence Liverpool’s decision on his future. Despite the draw, Liverpool remains atop the league, though questions about defensive lapses linger.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6c773/6c7738314965278ce595f41f9fceee32a3d27128" alt="Jamie Carragher Explodes Over Liverpool Keeper’s Blunder in Newcastle Thriller 131 Mohamed Salah"
Salah’s Heroics Overshadowed
Mohamed Salah once again demonstrated why he is one of the Premier League’s elite players, scoring twice to give Liverpool a late lead. His clinical finishes highlighted his consistency and ability to perform in crucial moments.
Unfortunately for Liverpool, Salah’s efforts were overshadowed by the defensive collapse. His second goal, a beautifully timed finish from a tight angle, seemed to secure the three points, but Kelleher’s misjudgment ensured the game ended in frustration for the Reds.
ChatG