Lee Carsley’s future as England’s interim manager remains a hot topic, with recent reports suggesting he won’t be given the role on a permanent basis. Despite leading the team to a 3-1 Nations League victory over Finland, Carsley’s mixed messaging and inconsistent performances have raised doubts about his long-term suitability for the job.
The speculation has intensified following England’s 3-1 defeat to Greece at Wembley. In the aftermath, Pep Guardiola’s name has re-emerged as a top candidate to succeed Gareth Southgate, despite Guardiola reportedly being close to signing a one-year contract extension at Manchester City.
Thomas Tuchel, the former Chelsea, PSG, and Bayern Munich coach, has also been heavily linked with the role, recently becoming the bookmakers’ favorite to take over. Tuchel’s odds have shortened from 4/7 to 13/8, making him the frontrunner according to William Hill, while Guardiola is priced at 5/1 with Betfred, and Carsley’s chances have lengthened to 8/1 with bet365.
Carsley, who initially made headlines for not singing the national anthem before his debut against Ireland, has impressed some with his fresh approach, having guided many of the current squad to victory in last year’s European Under-21 Championship. However, he has suggested the England role should go to a world-class manager with a proven record of winning major trophies, which may not have endeared him to the Football Association (FA). This stance leans towards the FA potentially seeking a foreign appointment, with Eddie Howe and Graham Potter—both at longer odds—not yet possessing major silverware.
While Potter was initially a strong candidate, his odds have drifted out to 11/1. Speculation continues around Guardiola and even Jurgen Klopp, though no decision on Southgate’s permanent successor is expected before the end of the year.
In the midst of the managerial uncertainty, the FA’s ultimate choice could define the future of English football for years to come.