Thomas Tuchel has been officially appointed as England’s new manager, set to take charge in January 2024 following Gareth Southgate’s resignation after Euro 2024. The German tactician, known for his success across Europe, brings a fresh approach as England looks to finally capture a major international trophy.
Tuchel, 51, joins on an 18-month deal, with a resume that boasts trophies at Borussia Dortmund, Paris Saint-Germain, Chelsea, and Bayern Munich. His appointment marks a shift in direction from Southgate’s era, which was often characterized by conservative, safety-first tactics. England hopes Tuchel’s more dynamic, aggressive style will be the key to ending their long-standing trophy drought.
Tactical Shift: From Southgate’s Caution to Tuchel’s Aggression
While Southgate found success in stabilizing England’s defense, his approach was often criticized for lacking creativity in key moments. Tuchel, on the other hand, is known for a more aggressive, high-pressing style out of possession. He demands intensity and boldness from his players, both defensively and offensively, traits England fans may not have seen regularly under Southgate.
Although Tuchel often utilized a back-three system at Chelsea, he predominantly favors a 4-2-3-1 setup, a formation he recently employed at Bayern Munich. This system aligns with England’s current squad structure and could offer more balance between attack and defense.
Key Players and Roles
Tuchel’s arrival also signals a potential tactical reshuffle for England’s stars. Harry Kane, who previously worked under Tuchel at Bayern, is likely to remain central to his plans. The England captain would reprise his role as a playmaker and goal-scorer, linking up with pacey wingers, much like he did with Leroy Sane and Serge Gnabry at Bayern. For England, Bukayo Saka and Anthony Gordon could be the key outlets on the flanks.
Midfield is another area where Tuchel’s vision could differ significantly from Southgate’s. Jude Bellingham, who has thrived in a more advanced role for Real Madrid, may find himself operating in a deeper midfield partnership with Declan Rice. This deeper role, similar to Bellingham’s Dortmund days, would allow him to combine defensive duties with attacking thrust, potentially becoming a second No. 10 alongside Cole Palmer.
Tuchel’s focus on maintaining defensive solidity could see a pragmatic backline. While Trent Alexander-Arnold’s attacking skills could be crucial at right-back, Tuchel might use Levi Colwill at left-back to offer balance. Meanwhile, John Stones and Marc Guehi appear to be the favored center-back pairing, providing a solid foundation in front of goalkeeper Jordan Pickford.
Rebuilding Key Players’ Futures
Some players who have struggled with form and fitness may find themselves back in the fold under Tuchel. Reece James, who excelled under the German at Chelsea, could be handed a lifeline in the national team—provided he can shake off his persistent injury issues. Similarly, Luke Shaw’s uncertain future due to his lack of game time at Manchester United leaves the door open for a new left-back option.
The Path Forward
Tuchel’s arrival is expected to bring a blend of attacking flair and tactical pragmatism, combining elements of Southgate’s tournament management with the more adventurous approach of interim boss Lee Carsley. If Tuchel can strike the right balance, England’s gamble on their third-ever foreign manager may prove to be a masterstroke, finally delivering the major success that has eluded the Three Lions for decades.
With the Nations League fixtures in November still under Carsley’s guidance, Tuchel will take the reins in the new year, aiming to build momentum ahead of the 2026 World Cup. The FA and fans alike will hope that this new chapter under Tuchel will be the one that delivers long-awaited international glory.